Most people who pick up The Screwtape Letters put it down at some point more confused than when they started, and it’s not because C.S. Lewis wrote badly. He wrote about as clearly as anyone in the twentieth century. The trouble is the book is built to disorient you on purpose, and once you see why, the disorientation turns into the point rather than the obstacle.
Here’s the first thing going on. The whole book is a series of letters from a senior devil, Screwtape, to his nephew Wormwood, a junior tempter working his first human case. Because the letters come from hell’s side of the desk, everything gets called by its opposite name. When Screwtape talks about “the Enemy,” he means God. When he talks about “Our Father Below,” he means Satan. The person Wormwood is trying to drag toward damnation is called simply “the patient.” Nobody flags this for you inside the text — you’re expected to catch the inversion and hold it the whole way through, and if you lose the thread even for a paragraph, the letter stops making sense. So that’s rule one, and once you have it, you basically never need it explained again: everything in these letters is upside down by design, said from the enemy’s own mouth.
Here’s the second thing. There’s no plot and no scenes. You never see the patient, never see Wormwood, never watch anything happen — you only get one side of a correspondence about things that happened off the page. Most reading experiences give you something to picture. This one gives you only argument and analysis, letter after letter, which asks more of your attention than a story would, especially early on before you’re used to the rhythm.
And the third thing is smaller but real: Lewis is writing in 1940s British English, for readers who knew wartime London, class assumptions, and a slower, more formal style of sentence than most of us read comfortably today. None of that is hard exactly, but it adds friction on top of the other two.
Put those three together and you get a book that a lot of thoughtful people quietly struggle with and rarely admit to, because it’s supposed to be the “accessible” Lewis.
So here is what we think this book is actually doing, once you get past those three obstacles, and it’s the thing we want this whole series to keep circling back to. Screwtape almost never advises Wormwood to manufacture some dramatic sin. He doesn’t say “get him to rob a bank” or “get him to have an affair.” Letter after letter, his actual instruction is much smaller and much more unsettling: use what’s already there. Use the patient’s fatigue. Use his taste in tea. Use an argument with his mother about a half-open door. Use a boring church service, a headache, a bus going past at the wrong moment. The devil’s real tool, according to this book, isn’t the exotic temptation — it’s the ordinary furniture of an ordinary day, treated as if it’s the only thing that’s real.
That’s why this book gets under people’s skin in a way plenty of more dramatic spiritual writing doesn’t. You don’t read it and think about some hypothetical grand sin you’d never commit. You read it and recognize yourself in a Tuesday afternoon. That’s the introspection this book is built to produce, and it’s the thread we’re going to trace letter by letter.
Here’s how the series works. Each letter gets its own companion post under the title “Dear Wormwood,” walking through what Screwtape is actually teaching in that letter, translated into plain modern language, and then showing where that same move shows up in ordinary life now. Each post also comes with two companion videos, so if reading dense 1940s prose isn’t how you take things in best, you can watch or listen to it worked through instead. Our study group will use these to prepare for discussion each week — but you don’t need to be in the group to use them.
Letter I is where we start, and it turns out to be almost a thesis statement for the whole method: an ordinary bus ride, an ordinary newsboy, and a man’s momentary flicker of real spiritual attention, quietly talked back down to sleep by nothing more dramatic than lunch.
All the Letters
Every “Dear Wormwood” post, in order. Start at Letter 1 and read along with your copy of the book.
- Letter 1 — The Bus and the Newsboy: why Screwtape says don’t argue a man out of his faith; just send him to lunch.
- Letter 2 — The Squeaky Boots in the Next Pew: a new convert, a pew full of ordinary neighbors, and the letdown that follows conversion.
- Letter 3 — The Lift of an Eyebrow: prayers for a mother’s soul, and the quiet irritations at her breakfast table.
- Letter 4 — Praying to the Ceiling Corner: how prayer gets swapped for a feeling or a mental picture of God.
- Letter 5 — Why War Doesn’t Help Hell: why comfort, not crisis, is the devil’s best weapon.
- Letter 6 — Love the Distant, Resent the Near: compassion for strangers, impatience with the people in the room.
- Letter 7 — When the Cause Becomes the Religion: how a political cause can quietly outgrow the faith it was meant to serve.
- Letter 8 — The Law of Undulation: why dry spiritual seasons are normal, and what they’re for.
- Letter 9 — Just a Phase: how a dry season and one well-chosen word can talk a man out of his convictions.
- Letter 10 — Two Parallel Lives: the slow cost of performing an attitude to fit a new crowd.
- Letter 11 — The Uses of Laughter: joy, fun, jokes, and the flippancy that keeps nothing serious.
- Letter 12 — The Gentle Slope: why the safest road away from God is the gradual one.
- Letter 13 — Tripe and Onions: how a simple, unfashionable pleasure breaks the spell of a performed life.
- Letter 14 — By Jove, I’m Being Humble: pride in your own humility, and what real humility looks like.
- Letter 15 — Hag-Ridden by the Future: why hell wants your mind in tomorrow rather than today.
- Letter 16 — Becoming a Connoisseur of Churches: church-shopping, critics versus pupils, and fights over candles.
- Letter 17 — All I Want Is a Cup of Tea: the gluttony of delicacy, and the small appetites that run a life.
- Letter 18 — To Be Is to Compete: hell’s philosophy of reality, and the myth of “being in love.”
- Letter 19 — Raw Material, Not a Verdict: why nothing is good or bad in itself, only in what it does to you.
- Letter 20 — The Terrestrial and the Infernal Venus: how our sense of attraction gets shaped, and what we’re really drawn to.
- Letter 21 — My Time Is My Own: the hidden assumption that our time and our lives belong to us.
- Letter 22 — Noise, Music, and Silence: why goodness unsettles hell, and why Noise is its favorite weapon.
- Letter 23 — Believe This, Not Because It’s True: reinvented Jesuses, and faith defended for every reason but its truth.
- Letter 24 — The Right Kind of Fish-Knife: how belonging to the right circle turns into quiet pride.
- Letter 25 — Christianity And…: faith bolted to trends, and the hunger for novelty.
- Letter 26 — Having Tea in the Garden: the polite unselfishness that ends in a real quarrel.
- Letter 27 — Heads I Win, Tails You Lose: prayer, distraction, and the bad-faith argument that prayer can’t work.
- Letter 28 — Time Is Hell’s Best Ally: why hell wants the patient alive for seventy ordinary years.
- Letter 29 — Courage at the Testing Point: why courage is the form every virtue takes under pressure.
- Letter 30 — What the World Is Really Like: exhaustion, false hope, and who gets to call something “real.”
- Letter 31 — So It Was You All Along: the final letter, and a lifetime that was never unaccompanied.
Reading along? The Screwtape Letters is often available free or at a steep discount on Kindle. The price varies by edition, so check before you buy.
Leave a Reply