Screwtape is delighted: the patient has made some new friends — a rich, fashionable, brightly skeptical couple who belittle everything with practiced ease. Nothing dramatic happened to draw the patient in. No argument, no seduction, no crisis of faith. Just an office acquaintance and, Screwtape notes approvingly, a subtle play of looks, tones, and shared laughter by which a person signals he’s part of the same crowd — a kind of betrayal so small the man himself barely notices he’s doing it, which is exactly what makes it effective.
The patient’s faith obviously sits in tension with everything his new friends assume about the world. Screwtape’s advice isn’t to hide that tension forever — just to delay him facing it. Shame, pride, vanity, and simple social awkwardness will do the delaying work on their own. In the meantime, the patient will laugh when he should stay serious, stay quiet when he should speak up, and gradually start performing cynical, sophisticated attitudes that aren’t really his — until, Screwtape notes with real relish, they become his. People tend to turn into whatever they keep pretending to be.
Then comes the sharpest move in the letter: once the patient can’t avoid noticing the contradiction between his faith and his new social circle, Screwtape doesn’t push him to abandon either side — he pushes him to enjoy the contradiction itself. Let him take a quiet pleasure in kneeling next to the ordinary grocer at church on Sunday, secretly amused that the grocer could never understand the clever, mocking world he inhabits on Saturday nights. Let him equally enjoy the coffee-and-cocktail crowd, flattered by the private sense of a “deeper” spiritual life they’d never grasp either. Screwtape’s phrase for it is almost admiring: the complete, balanced, complex man who sees round them all. In reality, he’s simply living two lives, being quietly false to two different groups of people — and instead of feeling the shame that ought to produce, he gets to feel sophisticated about it instead.
Notice what actually did the damage. Not an argument against Christianity. A dinner party, a shared laugh, a little vanity about being too complex to be fully known by anyone.
Where This Shows Up Now
It’s the small adjustments people make to fit in with a new social circle — the joke laughed along with, the opinion left unchallenged — that feel harmless in the moment and reshape a person’s character over months. It’s the quiet pride some people take in being “different people” in different rooms, treating it as sophistication rather than what it actually is: a kind of low-grade dishonesty toward everyone involved. It’s rationalizing a compromising friendship or environment as somehow doing good just by being present in it.
For Discussion
- Have you ever found yourself performing an attitude or opinion in a social setting that wasn’t really yours — and had it start to feel more natural over time?
- Screwtape’s line is that people tend to become what they keep pretending to be. Where might that be quietly true in your own life?
- Is there a version of “two parallel lives” in your own social world — a version of you that shows up in one circle and wouldn’t be recognized in another?
← Letter 9: Just a Phase · The Wormwood Files (index) · Letter 11: The Uses of Laughter →
Reading along? The Screwtape Letters is often available free or at a steep discount on Kindle. The price varies by edition, so check before you buy.
Leave a Reply